07/03/2014

A Reply to Rip Van Winkle (RVW) Article in Malaysia Insider On Malay Academics and UMNO. ( Article Title : `the Melayu academics are just jealous’ dated 27 February 2014 )


1.     The political bashing and slander on the Malays and UMNO institution is brewing again. However, the tempo now was orchestrated against the Malay academics whom were slammed a major 'below the belt' blow by labeling them as bunch of incompetence.

2.     The article written by RVW or perhaps a Malaysian under disguise in the Malaysian Insider could jolly well win the Oscar for being the most racist article ever written against the Malay academics. RVW single out one potent Malay academic as iconic and stamp the rest as substandard and deficient.

3.    There were actually two notable elements to this bizarre article which            were both    equally hard hitting against Malay academics and UMNO, the        strongest Malay political institution. What a better time to                            publish the article in the wake of the Kajang by-election.

4.    One would presume that RVM maybe an agent of some sought for leveling such atrocious and appalling attack on the Malay academics and UMNO. RVM may have a different target audience but definitely not the ordinary or reasonable man in streets of Kajang and certainly not the 'stuporous melayus' academics or professors whom he has labeled as english speaking freaks that strive on the vile UMNO ideology.

5.   The motive behind this 'No Holds Barred' condemnation and political innuendos against the Malay academics is baffling as much as it was unwarranted and incomprehensible. Naturally the article invites heavy criticism and the tide of battle has now turned against the beholder.

6.   RVM may be ignorant of the fact that english was never used as a yardstick to measure intellect and intellectualism, otherwise many great scientists would have been disqualified - so too were other great inventors who would all be labelled as unfit and inadequate under RVM's criteria.

7.   From his article, many would infer that RVM is a victim of his own intellectual morass judging from his myopic perspective and wild allegations as well as his lack of understanding on social complexities and wisdom. RVM and his academic idols were actually casualties of their own idiosyncrasies, thus blaming others for their own shortcomings.

8.   In his notoriously pathetic article, RVM also linked the so called 'stuporous' Malay academics as UMNO professors and went on his lambasting campaign against UMNO with distorted and malicious intents.

9.  Since independence, Malaysia has gone through many trials and tribulations to be a developed nation. When we were hit by the financial crisis in 1997, it was not the writer or his gang of pseudo intellectuals that came to the rescue but it was the BN government with the so called 'incompetent' UMNO leader defying  IMF formula took us out of the economics doldrums.

10.   UMNO has never been a racist party. If at all it was deficient, it was only because UMNO was just merely safeguarding the federal constitution, preserving the social contract and upholding the very tenets of our democracy which are now being relentlessly manipulated and maneuvered by its adversaries for their own political gains and agenda.

11.  The politics in Malaysia can never be the same again ever since the politics of lies, hatred and provocation propounded by unscrupulous politicians took centre stage and became the order of the day. It seems that the rule of law and respect has taken a back seat in today's era of neo-politics in Malaysia.

12.   If UMNO had ever subscribed to cronyism then it has discharged it's duties and responsibilities well as under BN and UMNO every citizen has equal and equitable access to education and economic opportunities. The fact that there is only one Malay businessman listed amongst the 10 richest man in Malaysia is another testimony that UMNO allows everyone to prosper irrespective of race, religion or creed.

13.  Yes, there maybe disgruntlement on the ground in regards to the behaviors and conducts of some dubious politicians within and outside the ruling party but to generalize everyone in the UMNO systems as racist, deficient and malingering is obnoxious and preposterous.

14.   Coming back to the Malay academics, it is too simplistic to benchmark them with top notch professors from America and Britain who hail from a different academic culture and environment. But still in many instances, our academics are far superior than those in the region to say the least. Our international publications have surpassed most of our immediate neighbors and as we speak more are being referred and published.  Of course, academics publications are also not devoid of political game just like anything else, its who you know.

15.   To say that there are hardly any non Malays professors left in the country is also a shooting statement in the dark. RVM may have written his article with malicious intent overlooking the true fact of the case. He may not be aware or deliberately whitewash the fact that in the five research universities, the Malays and non Malays professors are given equal window of opportunity in terms of research grants and funds. There are also almost equal number of Malay and non Malay recipients in the Merdeka Award, the most prestigious award given to academics, scholars and NGO for their contributions to society and the country.

 16.  16.   One cannot simply condemned another merely on their language                   orientation or preference. The Russians, the Germans and the Europeans         academics and scientists as well as the arab scholars would also be the          subject of parody under RVM definition. How does RVM categorize all             these non English speaking scientists, inventors and scholars if RVM used     english proficiency as a barometer to measure intellect and intellectualism.

17.  Malaysia is committed in her quest in restructuring it's society and recognizes that talent, hard work and discipline as well as unity and harmony as prerequisites to economic growth and prosperity.

18.   We hope that the Transformation Agenda being embark by the current government will not create human capital to the likes of RVM but one that stand steadfastly on respect, care and understanding. We need to build and transform Malaysia into a healthy and prosperous country to benefit every level of our society. There is no one size fit all. 

19.    Let us all put aside our differences and paranoia, at the same time pull all of our resources together and make our country, a better Malaysia. Many born again Malaysians who have come back to this land would appreciate that the grass is not always greener on the other side and they would vouch that there is no better place like home.




          Article written by Tengku Rethwan bin Tengku Mansor

No comments:

Post a Comment